An Eye-Opening Truth about ChatGPT in Medical Writing
On the journey of Digital Marketing, we have reached a new pit-stop named “ChatGPT”.
Innovated as a technical bridge in the world of writing, this AI tool is the new favorite for companies who believe investing in technology is a lifetime guarantee over human content writers.
Specifically speaking about healthcare content writing, can ChatGPT take the place of a human writer and provide the apt content from a vast ocean of medical information?
To understand the use of ChatGPT for healthcare content writing, I dived into the world of this AI bot and had a heart-to-heart conversation.
And here is my experience!
What is ChatGPT?
ChatGPT is an artificial intelligence chatbot that works on a pre-trained language model. This state-of-the-art chatbot was launched by OpenAI in November 2022. With the help of a pre-centric data feed, ChatGPT can answer almost every question like a conversation.
For a budget-restricted company, beginning its journey in digital marketing, ChatGPT can easily take the shape of an employee in the department of sales, marketing, programming, content writing, and customer support.
How to use ChatGPT?
ChatGPT can offer a level of versatility for a company’s team in several ways:
Sales
Suggest and provide tips on how to promote your product to related businesses or customers, thus minimizing the need for sales training. According to your prompts and requirements, ChatGPT can customize your sales pitch content.
Marketing
Learn the right way to market your product so that it can reach your target audience. ChatGPT can answer your need for:
- Marketing strategies and directions
- SEO and keyword requirements
- Ad copies for the website and blogs
Programming
To improve the core functionality and workflow of one’s business, ChatGPT can aid programmers to:
Content Creation
Perfect content can capture customer’s attention on your website right away, for which ChatGPT can:
- Create full-length blog articles
- Get near perfect, accurate data
- Customize the length and the language complexity
Customer Support
To save time and resources and provide alternative support for call center workers, the revolutionary chatbot can help to:
- Create complete customer service emails
- Alter the tone of the message (Promotion, Apology, Sales, Newsletter, etc.)
ChatGPT and Healthcare Content writing
With an ability to create highly accurate data-based text, ChatGPT has already cleared three levels of United States Medical Licensing Examinations (US MLEs) and the day is not far when it will be widely be used to create medical write-ups and journals. The vast and complex information in medical writing can be easily formatted into crisp content by ChatGPT.
So I tested ChatGPT’s medical writing abilities with some common examples.
Regular blog post (word-permitting)
Yes, ChatGPT can easily search for the data online and give you a blog post as per the word requirement and the language complexity.
Write a 1000-word blog post on diabetic foods:
ChatGPT on citing references
ChatGPT can create small content along with references based on your searches.
Write the diagnostic criteria for diabetes and cite references:
How about a lengthier blog post with more references?
Next, I pushed ChatGPT a little further to test its limit for citing multiple sources. For a 1000-word article on a common diabetes medicine, ChatGPT could cite only 3 sources, which was a little disappointing.
Write a 1000 word article on the use of Novolin for Diabetes and cite reference sources
ChatGPT for clinical trial write-ups
Clinical trials are an important part of medical writing and are continuously used in medical journals to prove the authenticity. Can ChatGPT help medical companies write about clinical trials? Let us check!
For a simple clinical trial protocol write-up, ChatGPT responded by providing a basic structure to conduct the relevant clinical trial.
Write a clinical trial protocol for Humulin R U-100
Further, ChatGPT could generate 5 relevant sources dated from 2005 to 2011 along with good content for small write-ups. However, no recent sources were cited.
Summarize clinical trial evidence on Novolin for diabetes with 5 source references cited
Next, I wanted to check if ChatGPT can give me more information on the same topic but with the latest references. This is the result that I got:
So, when pushed to limits, ChatGPT requested me to consult a proper healthcare individual if I needed more information on the clinical trials or to cite current sources for my write-ups. Also, the content shared lacked depth on the subject.
ChatGPT to analyze medical information and create a content strategy
For formulating content based on the analysis of medical information given, the chatbot has its limitations. ChatGPT could provide me with basic information without actually analyzing the content that I aimed for and failed in creating a strategy to highlight its importance.
Analyze the difference between different insulin receptor blockers and cite sources:
ChatGPT V/s Content Writers
In the age-old fight of man versus the machines, humans have always shown perseverance and achieved success. Standing by this motto, to find out more about my competition, I literally asked it!!
The answers that I got were completely honest and full of facts. ChatGPT confessed to its limitations of not being able to provide a personal touch to the content that is directed towards the target audience. It admits that it can provide us with a piece of basic information and structure, but the final work needs to be done by the brain behind the machine!
Can ChatGPT replace Human content Writers?
The battle of Authorship
Can we credit ChatGPT with the content that it provides?
It has been in debate for quite some time by the publishing houses and it was concluded that ChatGPT cannot be given the title of “Author” for the content.
ChatGPT cannot take full responsibility for the matter it provides and the integrity it is based on. However, the human author must appropriately attribute the content that has been generated through the chatbot (as stated by the World Association of Medical Editors, 2023), concerning scholarly publications.
ChatGPT and Plagiarism
ChatGPT cannot escape the challenges of the world of writing. It has to stand against all the barriers toward satisfied content creation. For it to do so, the content submitted by the AI should be plagiarism free. ChatGPT doesn’t copy-paste from the internet and hence, can be considered non-plagiarized. However, certain tools like Turnitin has detected scores as low as 5% plagiarized when produced with the use of AI.
ChatGPT: Limitations and Challenges
Like every other machine, this AI Chatbot has its own limitations.
Data limited to the year 2021
Since its conception in November 2021, ChatGPT can only provide data previous to that time and cite sources as latest as 2021. When specifically asked to retrieve information for the year 2022, the chatbot responded truthfully, with its inability to do the same.
Limited practical Information
Since ChatGPT lacks the emotional quotient of a human writer, the content that it shares is purely based on the fact and figures found across the internet. ChatGPT cannot conduct interviews, trials or collect data as and when required. Such tasks can never be fully automated by chatbots.
Limited depth on the subject matter
As seen above, while stating the examples of content creation in clinical trials, the chatbot showed its limitations. It provided us with basic data and old references, to begin with. Lengthy articles were shallow and lacked creativity. It was only a formulation of collected data provided on the internet.
Takeaway: Quality over Quantity
While writing this article, I learned that the bot’s only aim is to assist a writer. It can’t replicate the creativity, nuance, and emotional touch that a human can bring to medical writings.
Yes, it can help the companies by providing a quantity of matter for the content, search data and answer questions (like with Google Assistant, Alexa, Siri, Bard, etc.), reducing the time and money investment, but in the long run, you will need human intervention to create a quality that impacts.
Thus, this AI chatbot is not the ultimate solution for your content related problems.
Special Note: For my fellow healthcare content writers, there is no need to announce ChatGPT as your competition. We must learn to advance ourselves with technology, as it’s a mutual process of bringing out the best in each other. ChatGPT needs guidance and that’s where we, the human content writers, can add value to its existence!
Originally published at https://writerena.com on February 18, 2023.
